Skip to content

Enter delivery address

Frosty's Ice Cream

Frosty's Ice Cream

• Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • Comfort Food • Desserts • Info

5500 Broadway St., Lancaster, NY 14086

Get it delivered to your door.

x $0 delivery fee

new customers

Enter address

to see delivery time

Every Day

12:00 PM - 8:30 PM

Soft-Real Custard
- Soft-Real Custard
  $2.25
  Real custard.
Milkshakes
- Milkshakes
  $4.40
Sundaes
- Sundaes
  $3.75
  Includes whip cream, nuts, and cherry.
Speciality Sundaes
- Speciality Sundaes (Large)
  $6.60
  Our signature warm brownie sundae.
Banana Splits
- Row Boat
  $6.60
- Yacht Big Enough for Two
  $7.20
Hard-Perry's Ice Cream
- Hard-Perry's Ice Cream
  $2.25
  Perry's ice cream.
Arctic's
- Arctic's
  $3.40
Lemon Delight
- Lemon Delight
  $4.80
  Lemon sorbet blended with vanilla custard.
Fruity Fizzy's
- Fruity Fizzy's
  $4.80
  Lemon sorbet blended with fresh fruit.
Floats
- Floats (Large) (20 oz)
  $5.00
  Price includes 20 ounces bottle of pop.
Quarts To Go
- With Custard
  $7.40
- With Hard Ice Cream
  $8.65
Ice Cream Cakes
- Ice Cream Cakes
  $25.75
  Made with custard. Fudge and chocolate crunchies in every cake.
Extra's
Beverages

Javascript disabled

Javascript disabled

Javascript is needed to run Postmates. You can try enabling it or visiting the website with a browser that supports Javascript.