My Tomato Pie

At My Tomato Pie, we believe that nothing beats the comfort of a hot bowl of homemade soup, especially during the chilly Buffalo months! That’s why we make our soups fresh every single day, right in our kitchen.

You can always count on our two signature soups:
Our Specialty Tomato Basil Soup – Rich, creamy, and bursting with flavor, it's a customer favorite!
Minestrone Soup – A hearty classic, packed with fresh vegetables and savory broth.

When the Buffalo weather gets colder, we like to add a third rotating soup to the mix! This extra option changes frequently—sometimes even throughout the day—so you’ll always find something new and delicious to warm you up.

Includes side of pasta salad, chips, or apple

Includes side of pasta salad, chips, or apple

Includes side of pasta salad, chips, or apple

Includes side of pasta salad, fries, homemade chips, or apple.

At My Tomato Pie, we're serving up My Burger Bar’s legendary custom burger blend—crafted from whole sirloin and brisket primal cuts for a flavor that’s truly unmatched.

We take pride in crafting the perfect burger from the ground up—literally. Our custom blend starts with whole sirloin and brisket primal cuts, expertly combined to deliver unmatched flavor, rich juiciness, and a perfectly balanced bite. Every bite is packed with bold, beefy goodness, making these burgers an instant favorite.

All burgers come with your choice of one delicious side: pasta salad, macaroni salad, potato salad, crispy fries, coleslaw, or a fresh apple.

🔥 Experience the burger that keeps you coming back for more! 🔥

🐟 Fresh Haddock Every Wednesday & Friday at My Tomato Pie! 🐟

Every Wednesday and Friday, we’re serving up the freshest beer-battered haddock! Choose between a hearty 12oz meal or a tasty haddock sandwich—both guaranteed to satisfy your seafood cravings. 🐟

Perfectly golden and crispy, our haddock is the ultimate treat for fish lovers. Whether you’re in the mood for a full meal or a lighter option, we’ve got you covered.

Stop by and enjoy the best haddock in town! See you this week!

includes side or bleu cheese and celery. You choose your sauce - Hot,Medium, Mild, BBQ, Hot BBQ, Garlic Parmesan, Sweet Chili, Sweet Teriyaki

Add small house salad to any Entree for only $3

Add small house salad to any Pasta for only $3

Requires Extra Time. “Gluten-Free” designations are based on information provided by our ingredient suppliers.
Warning: normal kitchen operations involve shared cooking and preparation areas. We are therefore unable to guarantee that any menu item is free from gluten or any other allergen, and we assume no responsibility for guests with food allergies or sensitivities. Please inform a manager of any allergies when ordering.

All calzones include a side of tomato sauce or bleu cheese.

Pinsa is a traditional Roman-style flatbread that has gained popularity as an alternative to pizza. Its name is derived from the Latin word pinsere, which means "to stretch or press." Pinsa has a unique texture and flavor profile due to its distinctive dough, which is made from a blend of different flours such as wheat, rice, and soy. This combination, along with a higher water content and longer fermentation time, results in a lighter, crispier crust that is easier to digest compared to traditional pizza dough.

Though rooted in ancient Roman recipes, pinsa has seen a resurgence in popularity, especially in Italy and increasingly around the world, thanks to its health-conscious appeal and versatility.

Choice of soft drink in spill proof cup.